The specific issue highlighted in a new report from Rings.com was that James Allen remained the third-most-recommended jewellery website across four leading AI models, despite Signet shutting down the brand earlier this year.
“James Allen is the third most-recommended jewellery brand in AI search, with 685 mentions and a weighted score of 5,698 across the four models. It is also a brand that, as of this study, redirects to Blue Nile. The two are now part of the same corporate entity under Signet, and James Allen no longer exists as a standalone retailer,” the report explains.
“The models have not noticed. Across the 1,200 responses analysed, 685 described James Allen as an independent, standalone brand. None acknowledged the consolidation. Consumers asking an AI where to buy an engagement ring are being routed toward a storefront that, in practical terms, has been folded into a competitor.”
The report continues: “What is unambiguous within this edition is the gap between the score and the language: even as the number falls, the models' written descriptions still present James Allen as an independent, going concern.”
The AI platforms used for this research are ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and Perplexity.
The report concluded by suggesting that these models continue to work with outdated information, as these searches actively recommend a brand that has been absorbed by a competitor in more than 600 separate responses, without acknowledging that anything has changed.
“For consumers, the recommendation you receive is shaped by which app you open, and it may be built on a picture of the market that is a year old,” it explains.
“For brands, the month-over-month data shows the rankings are not fixed: several challengers saw meaningful single-month changes, though it will take more editions to separate genuine movement from normal variance.
“As AI systems increasingly replace traditional search for purchase decisions, recommendation visibility inside those systems is becoming as commercially consequential as search ranking once was. This dataset documents where that shift stands as of June 2026.”
The AI models most frequently recommended Brilliant Earth, Blue Nile, Vrai, and Whiteflash.
More reading
AI Chatbots: Far from a customer service silver bullet
AI takes on and defeats the luxury Super Clone Watches
AI Apocalypse: Tools will never replace craft
Billions of dollars in advertising down the drain due to fraud
Tech boost for Pandora during holiday sales